What should the gender police be looking at with the South African runner, Semenya? Genitalia, Xy XX?

Inside the head — what she wants to be known as ‘boy or girl’
Should she be able to run as a girl because she was raised as a girl and identifies as a girl? Even though she may have other chromosome things happening?
David, does anything trump? Does external genitalia mean the most?

It would be nice is everything was that easy. However, sex and gender are much, much more complicated than that. Maybe this will help explain it:

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/08/22/sports/22runner.html?_r=1

South African runner Semenya Caster gender testing

Leopard Skin Area Rug 2×8 Runner African Modern Carpet – Actual 1′ 10″ x 7′ 3″ $24.99

Zebra Skin Area Rug 2×8 Runner African Modern Carpet – Actual 1′ 10″ x 7′ 3″ $24.99

MODERN beige ZEBRA 2×8 area rug AFRICAN stripes RUNNER : Actual Size 2’7″ x 7’4″ $101.60

Leopard Skin Area Rug 2×8 Runner African Modern Carpet – Actual 1′ 10″ x 7′ 3″ $24.99

Zebra Skin Area Rug 2×8 Runner African Modern Carpet – Actual 1′ 10″ x 7′ 3″ $24.99

Exotic African Zebra Skin Safari 3×16 Runner Area Rug ACTUAL SIZE 2’8 x 15’5 $69.99

OLD AFRICAN DAN MASK RUNNER RACING $250.00

Lot of 2 Vintage Indian or African Hand Made Table Runner 22″X84″ $2.99

Exotic African Zebra Skin Safari 3×10 Runner Area Rug ACTUAL SIZE 2’8 x 15’5 $45.99

African Inspired Kente Cloth Scarf Table Runner Sash Fashion Home Decor India $14.95

African Inspired Kente Cloth Scarf Table Runner Sash Fashion Home Decor India $14.95

African Inspired Kente Cloth Scarf Table Runner Sash Fashion Home Decor India $14.95

1.10′ x 7.3′ African Zebra Stripe Skin Design Area Rug Mat Wall Hanging Runner $22.89

African table runner: Black history month decorations: fair trade from Congo $19.99

AFRICAN AMERICAN ART Excellence Runner Motivational $4.45

Table Runner Teardrop African Textil Dsenyo Crafted Fair Trade Malawi Gifts $38.50

Table Runner Red Yellow Fans African Textil Dsenyo Fair Trade Malawi Gifts $38.50

Table Runner Malawi Red African Textile Handmade Dsenyo Fair Trade Malawi Gifts $38.50

AFRICAN AMERICAN ART Excellence Runner Motivational $8.95

Market Place African American Tapestry Table Runner ~ Annie Lee $19.99

Antique AFRICAN LION Walkway Throw Rug Runner Mat 38″ x 21″ Hanging Decoration $31.99

African American Annie Lee Market Place Jacquard Tapestry Table Runner 36″ NEW $8.94

VINTAGE VERY COOL WOVEN AFRICAN GIRAFFE RUG THROW RUNNER WALL-ART WOW!! $39.99

LEOPARD CAMEL PRINT AFRICAN SAFARI rug runner 20″x33″ nice size $25.00

Central African Republic 1972 Postal Runner Youth Center VF MNH (174-5) $7.12

NEW Area Rugs Carpet African Queen Red 2×7 Runner $96.00

Wind Runner -the Story of an African Antelope G.W.Barrington 1951 1st edition $9.95